1. Committees
  2. Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee

LORDS

Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee

LordsSelectest. 17 Dec 2003Email ↗● Actively Monitored

Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee in the House of Lords examines impact assessments accompanying secondary legislation to assess whether they meet Cabinet Office standards and properly analyse regulatory effects. The Committee operates as a select committee and conducts oral evidence sessions with government departments and external witnesses. Its scrutiny occurs after statutory instruments are laid but before they take effect, allowing time for recommendations to influence implementation. Recent work has focused on Home Office immigration rules, where the Committee analysed the accompanying impact assessment to evaluate how the department assessed costs, benefits, and compliance burdens on affected stakeholders. The Committee's role is to identify deficiencies in impact assessment quality rather than to block legislation, reporting findings to both Houses to inform parliamentary debate on secondary instruments.

Recent Sessions

View all (1)
Home Office: Immigration Rules IA
2 commit5 pos1 concern1 disag

28 Oct 2025

The session scrutinised the Home Office’s handling of impact assessments and explanatory material for Immigration Rules HC 997 and HC 1298, and the related governance processes. The committee pressed for publication of impact information alongside rule changes, warning against “policy by press release.” Ministers defended cross-department modelling and sign-off processes, while committing to publish the impact assessment by year-end and to continue work across government to reduce migration. The discussion also covered refugee family reunion policy, including pauses, changes, and a spring 2026 review, and highlighted concerns about consistency between PM statements and department actions. Across questions, the committee urged improved explanatory material, clearer accountability, and quicker, more transparent engagement with Parliament. Key commitments include publishing the impact assessment by 2025-12-31 and continuing interdepartmental coordination to improve scrutiny and policy clarity.

Recent Commitments

Recent Recommendations

No recommendations captured yet.

Entity Sentiment

Home Office1 mention
Mike Tapp1 mention
Dan Hobbs1 mention
Minister Kinnock1 mention
Ruth1 mention
PositiveNeutralNegative